Pit Barrel Cooker Reviews and How to build an Ugly Drum Smoker

FOR YOUR MONEY, YOU CAN’T BUY A BETTER SMOKER THAN BUILDING YOUR OWN UGLY DRUM SMOKER.

Pit Barrel Cooker Reviews

Fuel type Charcoal
Primary Capacity 240 square inches
Weight 60 lbs
Dimensions 30 x 20 x 20 in
Warranty 1 year on defective merchandise
Our Rating 5 stars and 729 + customer reviews on Amazon
Purchase link Get the latest price on Amazon

 

Can I interest you in a smoker you can easily build yourself which will be designed well enough to smoke food for upwards of 10 hours without the need for constant maintenance? The UDS is a true set-it-and-forget-it style of smoker.

18-1/2 in. Classic Pit Barrel Cooker PackageThis is a great #MeatGeek project with an insatiable drive for DIY tasks. You’ll need some specific tools, but if you’re a hardcore DIY-er then you probably already have all the tools you need.

Although it might sound complicated, building one of these beasts is actually pretty easy for the average do it yourselfer.

This walkthrough takes you through everything you need and how to assemble your very own UDS. The hardest part of the entire project is acquiring the 55 gallon drum — even that isn’t all that difficult — more on this in a second. Should you decide that you like the idea of owning a UDS, but don’t want to get your hands dirty, it’s okay, there’s a premade kit you can buy from Amazon. This kit show ups at your door with all the parts ready to be assembled…almost like Ikea furniture – it’s okay, we won’t tell.

There are a lot of different ways to make these, for example, some plans call for a welder, we swapped out that step and went a different route.

Build quality

The PBC is made of high quality durable steel. Originally a 20-gauge, it has now been upgraded to a sturdier 18-gauge. Its porcelain enamel coating makes it extremely resistant to weather. It performs well at high altitude, and can keep your meat cooking even if it’s minus 15 outside.

If you are planning to keep it outside in harsh conditions it may still be wise to cover it up if you want to keep it in good shape. You can purchase their own custom-fit cover separately for $29.95.

Easy to use

If you’ve struggled with a cheap offset smoker, or even relied on using the snake method on a old Weber kettle, you’ll be very happy with how easy this smoker is to use. We recently included it on our list of best smokers for beginners.

The theory behind the Pit Barrel cooker is the famous minion method. Rather than pouring a chimney full of hot coals in at once and then needing to refuel every few hours, the minion method involves adding a few light coals to a larger pile of unlit charcoal.

As the light coals burn down, the unlit coals below start to ignite. This allows you to get many hours out of a single load of charcoal.

In this video you can see how easy it is to setup and start smoking on the pit barrel cooker.

You can regulate airflow by adjusting the rotatable steel plate over the air hole near the bottom of the drum. The manufacturers also recommend setting the air vent depending on your elevation:

  • 0-2000 Ft the vent should be 1/4 open
  • 2000-5000 Ft the vent should be 1/2 open
  • 5000-8000 Ft the vent should be 3/4 open
  • And above 8000 Ft leave the vent fully open.

18-1/2 in. Classic Pit Barrel Cooker PackageThis smoker isn’t designed to give you a high degree of temperature control. We would recommend against fiddling with the vents, and you are going to get the occasional burst when fat drips from the hanging meat.

This is really is a set it and forget it smoker. The air flow allows you to maintain fairly steady temperatures for 8-12 hour cooks without adding charcoal. And if you really want to dial in your temperatures you can still install a automatic temperature controller.

The stainless steel hooks hang easily on the steel lateral bars at the top of the barrel and the removable grill grate offers no resistance at all. Whether it’s half chickens and racks of ribs, or a tray of salmon, the PBC produces great results with minimal effort. And Its compact size and lightness make it easy to take your barbecuing out on the road without issue.

This unit does require regular cleaning to maintain a top quality cook. For extra ease, there is a removable ash pan that you can add for $29.95 which is recommended if you can stretch for it.

Cons

You are somewhat restricted in how you control temperature. The adjustable plate can vary temperature by 50 degrees or so to account for ambient air temperature and wind but it’s not easily adjusted on the fly. Make sure you read the instructions, and have a good quality wireless thermometer on hand which can easily be threaded through a hole in the barrel.

While you ‘can’ use this as a grill, it makes a better dedicated smoker. Using the grill grate can be a bit awkward as you need to reach a bit too far in when it’s flipping time. We recommend getting long barbecue tongs to be on the safe side, or just stick with a Weber Kettle for your grilling needs.

Get the latest price on Amazon.

How to build an Ugly Drum Smoker

There are a lot of ways to build and create a UDS. Use your own DIY-er knowledge and tweak these plans to make your UDS perfect for you.

In a nutshell, it goes like this… get a 55-gallon drum, then strategically drill a bunch of holes into it. Build a charcoal basket and find a 22-inch grilling grate to place inside. Finally, attach some plumbing valves to work as the air inlets. And voilà you’ve got yourself a one of a kind ugly drum smoker. Insider secret… it’s not ugly at all. When you’re done you’ll see for yourself how awesome it is.

Ugly Drum Smoker Parts

How to build an Ugly Drum Smoker

 

Drum

How to build an Ugly Drum Smoker

55 Gallon Drum

Look for a new non-lined barrel. While you can use a torch and some elbow grease to remove any possible toxic liners, it’s easier to purchase a non-lined barrel. You can find them on eBay or other various online marketplaces. Expect to pay about $75 or less for a new non-lined barrel.

Charcoal Basket

  • Charcoal grate
  • Steel mesh – around 45 x 9 inches
  • Bolts (4″ long), washers, nuts and lock nuts – 6 of each
  • U-bolts – 2 each

Charcoal Basket: Legs

Charcoal Basket

Assembly

Handel & Grill Grate

  • Door handle – at least 1 for the lid, but get 2 more to attach to the sides of the barrel for easier handling.
  • Standard grill grate 22.5” – get 2 (one for meat, one for a water pan)

Air Intake

All Parts Are 3/4ths Inch

  • 3 Steel pipe nipples
  • 3 Steel pipe caps
  • 3 Conduit nuts
  • 1 Ball valve

How to build an Ugly Drum Smoker

Creating The Basket – Easy Peasy

How to build an Ugly Drum SmokerNo Welder, No Problem

Some of us don’t have access to a welder. Others, have no business operating one, myself included (the first basket I welded came out looking like a middle school shop project). I found this method online, and it is by far the easiest way to create a basket. Simple, yet practical. No welding required – it can be completed in under an hour (depending how long you spend on step 1).

Step 1 – Bend Ring

Bend a 45″ x 9″ sheet of expanded metal around a propane take. The propane tank is ideal, however, it still takes a bit of finesse.

How to build an Ugly Drum Smoker

Step 2 – Fasten Ring

Secure the cylinder with two bolts using washers and nuts.

How to build an Ugly Drum Smoker

Step 3 – Fasten Legs

Fasten the 4″ bolts to the grate as shown.

How to build an Ugly Drum Smoker

Step 4 – Fasten Basket

Attached the basket you bended to the charcoal grate using the U-Bolt. Simple.

How to build an Ugly Drum Smoker

Drilling & Mounting The Assembly

Now we will prepare the drum for assembly in a few quick steps.

If you don’t already own a step bit, I can recommend this one which will set you back about $10 to $15. You can easily spend $60 on a good titanium bit at your local hardware store, but if you don’t plan on using it on the job site everyday the recommended one is perfectly fine. After all, we’re on a budget here.

The recommended bit goes from ¼ inch to 1 3/8. You’ll use ¼ inch for the holes that hold the cooking grate and handle.  1 inch will be perfect for the exhaust lid holes and the air intake at the bottom.

The Lid

Drill 8 evenly spaced 1 inch exhaust holes all the way around the lid.

How to build an Ugly Drum Smoker

The handle

Mount the handle to the lid with four 1/4 inch holes (or however you see fit based on your handle).

How to build an Ugly Drum Smoker

Grate supports

Measure about 7 inches from the top of your barrel and drill four 1/4 inch holes evenly spaced around the barrel with your step drill.

You’ll place the nuts and bolts in these holes to support the grilling grate.

How to build an Ugly Drum Smoker

Air Intake Valve/Holes

Drill three 1 inch holes evenly spaced, about 3 inches off the bottom. Two of these holes will hold the capped ¾ inch steel nipples and the third hole will hold the ball valve.

How to build an Ugly Drum Smoker

Optional – Create an additional area for increased functionally features

If you have a second grill grate you can work it into the bottom part of the barrel to provide a place for searing, dropping in a heat diffuser, water pan, drip pan, etc.

To add the second grate you’ll be repeating the same steps you just completed in step 4. Measure 12 to 14 inches from the bottom and drill four 1/4 inch holes all the way around.

How to build an Ugly Drum Smoker

You want to make sure this second grate will sit above the charcoal basket you made. Double check the height before you start drilling these holes.

Congrats, You’ve Built Your Own Uds Smoker

Now you’re pretty much ready to go.

Barrel Smoker & Accessories

If you don’t have a leave in thermometer like the iGrill3, Fireboard or a trusty Maverick thermometer, drill in a hole for a standard grill thermometer. However, I certainly recommend ditching those standard analog thermometers; they’re almost never accurate. Temperature matters; especially when smoking meat for 8+ hours.

Depending on your DIY-er drive, and how much beer you have left, you can paint your barrel before completing the final assembly. Make sure to use paint that is rated for 500+ degrees. You can even find paint specifically made for barbecues. Feel free to have fun with pimping your UDS and making it totally your own custom creation.

Why you should buy the Pit Barrel Cooker?

For a first time smoker this is a great option. Reliable, durable, consistent and great value for money at its current asking price. That and the fact that it is delivered to your door ready-to-go is a real boon for the newcomer. The Pit Barrel Cooker will have you feeling like a BBQ master in no time at all.

However, what comes as a blessing for the newbie could be considered a curse for the more dedicated hobbyist. There is no room at all for customization with the PBC.

Get the latest price on a PBC from Amazon.

How to Season a New Uds Smoker

It’s always a good idea to season your new grill. To do this load your newly created charcoal basket (it should hold almost a full 20lbs bag of charcoal) with charcoal mixed with a few wood chunks for flavor. Leave a little room on top because we’ll be adding hot coals to the top.

Load your chimney with about a dozen or two coals. Once there hot drop them on top of the charcoal basket that you loaded with coal and wood chunks.

Open all of the vents and put the lid on.

Now, for this seasoning you’ll want to cook something with a lot of fat (bacon, breakfast sausage, chorizo, etc.). Add the meat to the center of the grate.

Next, have fun discovering how your new UDS will keep the perfect temperature. Play around with the air intake regulator and the valve caps; covering and uncovering these capped ends with a magnet. If you have the charcoal going property you should be around a perfect 250°F. The best part of an Ugly Drum Smoker is you should remain at 250°F for upwards of 10 hours. The seasoning process should be completed after two hours, then, you’re ready for your first smoke!